Which Hobbit is the best?
Metacritic score: 66. The best Hobbit movie, according to Metacritic, is The Desolation of Smaug which has the most satisfying balance between action and character development in the Hobbit movies as the main bulk of the adventure from the original book plays out.
Is The Hobbit older than Harry Potter?
For the record, J.R.R. Tolkien published “The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring” in 1954. (“The Hobbit” was published several years earlier in 1937.) The first Harry Potter book, “Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone” came out in 1997. “Overall, I like Lord of the Rings.
Where did the Hobbit go wrong?
One of the main problems in adapting The Hobbit is that Smaug the dragon doesn’t fit the mold of a modern villain, being little more than a hoarder with a bad temper. To solve the problem, Jackson’s Smaug was more vicious than his book counterpart, and this alteration worked well enough for film.
Who is the best LOTR character?
10 Best Lord Of The Rings Characters, Ranked
- 1 Aragorn.
- 2 Legolas.
- 3 Gandalf.
- 4 Gollum.
- 5 Samwise Gamgee.
- 6 Gimli.
- 7 Frodo Baggins.
- 8 Pippin & Merry.
Is LOTR better than Harry Potter?
Harry Potter has much more rounded and relatable characters and (I would argue) better storytelling than LOTR, but LOTR is way better at world-building and lore. The Harry Potter series does character development beautifully.
Is Lord of the Rings better than Harry Potter?
Lord of the Rings is a better piece of literature than Harry potter. I grew up on Harry Potter – started reading the first book when I was just 5 or 6 I think. It is a magical series, no doubt, but it is on a different grading curve than the work of J.R.R. Tolkien.
What is the difference between Harry Potter and The Hobbit?
Hobbit being in the epic fantasy genre, a larger world can be expected. Harry Potter is about events in a particular place or a set of places, while Hobbit is more about a journey of characters over a large area. Harry Potter has a strong and strict magical construct. The magic doesn’t grow stronger by any way except 1.
Why do people compare the Harry Potter books to the movies?
The mentor of both books were wizards with long white beards. The actors who played the protagonists even looked similar! Most of all, when two fantasy movie series come out in relatively short time to one another, they’re going to be compared. Especially when the movies overlap in release.
Is Harry Potter a good book for adults?
Harry Potter is a book designed for young readers (and as a humongous fan myself, adult readers will appreciate it too) with a less dark perspective on things than Lord of the Rings. First of all, let me compliment the book. Rowling’s description of the book was absolutely flawless.