Why is Harappan civilization difficult?

So far, the Indus writing system could not be translated because the texts are too short, we have no bilingual inscription and we do not which language or languages were transcribed. Moreover, it is possible that it worked differently from any other writing system of the same general period.

Why is the Harappan script not yet deciphered?

Discovered from nearly 4,000 ancient inscribed objects, including seals, tablets, ivory rods, pottery shards, etc., the Indus inscriptions are one of the most enigmatic legacies of the Indus Valley civilization which have not been deciphered due to the absence of bilingual texts, extreme brevity of the inscriptions.

Can we read Harappan script?

In spite of many attempts, the ‘script’ has not yet been deciphered, but efforts are ongoing. There is no known bilingual inscription to help decipher the script, and the script shows no significant changes over time. However, some of the syntax (if that is what it may be termed) varies depending upon location.

Why was the Harappan script a mysterious script?

The Harappan script is called enigmatic because of the following reasons: Most inscriptions were short, the longest contained about 26 signs, each sign stood for a vowel or consonant. Sometimes it contained wider space, sometimes shorter, had no consistency. Till today, the script remains undeciphered.

What are the drawbacks to our understanding of the Indus Valley civilization?

Answer: It is probable that cholera was also rife, since there was likely to have been seepage between the drinking water and sewage systems. Poor health in the centres of administration would have had a deleterious effect on the Harappan bureaucracy and political control.

Why we still can’t read the writing of the ancient Indus civilization?

There is no consensus on how to read them, although dozens of speculative decipherments have been proposed over the past century. Complicating efforts, the underlying language the script is tied to is disputed, and there are complex modern-day political ramifications to the question.

What difficulties have been faced by historians in deciphering the Indus script?

It is challenging for historians to read the inscription those inscriptions that were written thousands of years ago as some letters may be faintly over time. Moreover, they can not be always sure about the exact meaning of the deciphered word due to the very fact that meaning of deciphered words changes with time.

Why is Harappan script considered as an enigmatic script mention any two difficulties faced by the historian in deciphering the Indian script what are its features?

Harappan script is an enigmatic script because of following reasons: (1) Most inscriptions are short and the longest one containing about 26 signs. (2) These scripts were not alphabetical as it has too many signs (between 375 to 400).

Why do archaeologist and historians find Harappan script enigmatic explain reasons?

Answer: Archaeologists and historians found Harappan script enigmatic. The reasons behind it were: Harappan seals usually had a line of writing, containing the name and title of the owner, sometimes the motif conveyed a meaning to those who could not read.

Why is it unlikely that Indus civilization was destroyed by war?

Some historians believed the Indus civilisation was destroyed in a large war. Indus Valley people seem to have been peaceful. If they had an army, they have left few signs of weapons or battles. It’s more likely that the cities collapsed after natural disasters.

Do you agree that the Indus Valley Civilization declined due to ecological disturbance?

Historians generally agree now that the death of the Indus Valley civilisation was not caused by a single dramatic event; it was, instead, a slow decline attributable to a combination of factors.

Can the Harappan language be deciphered?

In my opinion the Harappan language has been deciphered, and it was an early member of the Dravidian language family. The main hurdles in the decipherment of the Indus script include: 5. apparent discontinuity in the cultural traditions at the decline of the Indus Valley civilization.

Why is it difficult to understand the Indus Valley script?

Answer: The Indus Valley script is still difficult to understand because it is completely unrelated to any writing system used today and is unrelated to any.. Answer: thus it is difficult to understand the script of Indus valley . Click to read further detail. Simply so, why it is difficult to understand the Harappan script?

Why the Indus writing system could not be translated?

So far, the Indus writing system could not be translated because the texts are too short, we have no bilingual inscription and we do not which language or languages were transcribed. Moreover, it is possible that it worked differently from any other writing system of the same general period.