Why was Remus not the Secret Keeper?

If James was so certain, it must have been Sirius’s persuasion that changed his mind – and that’s where the timing became important. And while it’s strange that Pettigrew avoided suspicion, it seemed Sirius, at least, believed Lupin was the spy, hence why Lupin wasn’t told about the Secret-Keeper switch.

Did James and Lily think Remus was the spy?

Out of everyone close to James and Lily, Remus was the one most likely to be the spy (based on the situation). Not even Remus knew that it was switched to Peter because the level of distrust was so significant. Peter was viewed as too weak and cowardly to be the spy. They vastly underestimated him.

Why did Sirius think Remus was the traitor?

Sirius was thought to be a traitor since he seemed like the obvious choice for Secret Keeper, and not even Lupin knew of the switch. He also went to Azkaban, and Peter was suspected to be dead. That’s why Sirius was thought of the traitor.

Did Remus think Sirius was innocent?

1 Lupin Believed Sirius Was Guilty By his own admission, Lupin believed Sirius was guilty of dooming Harry’s parents and committing the mass-murder he was imprisoned for. He believed this throughout Prisoner of Azkaban, only understanding he was innocent when he saw Peter Pettigrew on the Marauder’s Map.

Who was the Secret Keeper for the Potters?

Peter Pettigrew
Peter Pettigrew, the Secret Keeper for the Potter family who betrayed them to Voldemort. Sirius Black was originally meant to be the secret keeper for James and Lily Potter, but Sirius thought Voldemort was on to him (he thought that Remus Lupin was a spy), therefore passing on the Secret Keeper to Peter Pettigrew.

Who was the Potter’s Secret Keeper?

Who betrayed Lupin?

One of the reasons Pellegrini had his downfall in Lupin Part 2 was due to Anne’s betrayal; she called Guedira and told him about her husband’s actions. Anne isn’t exactly a confrontational person despite knowing that Pellegrini’s framing of Babakar was wrong.

Which of the four Marauders was the closest to James Potter?

Of the four Marauders, it was always James and Sirius who were the closest. Lupin and Pettigrew were welcomed into their midst, but the group revolved around James and the man who would be Best Man at his wedding.

Why did the Potters appoint Sirius as their secret keeper?

As James’ most trusted friend, the Potters appointed him as their Secret Keeper. This was a complex piece of magic which would mean that the Potters could never be found… unless Sirius divulged their location.

Why can’t Sirius and Remus ever contact each other?

For Sirius and Remus, life circumstances dictated that they’d barely be able to contact each other at all. After escaping from Azkaban in the third installment of the beloved franchise, Sirius didn’t get the chance to have his name cleared, and was forced to live in isolation.

What happened to the Marauders in Harry Potter?

As Harry Potter fans know, J.K. Rowling has never been afraid to hit us square in the feels. Some of the most beloved characters, such as the wise and kindly Albus Dumbledore, lost their lives in super sad circumstances. Perhaps the most tragic tale in the series, however, is that of the Marauders.